How close is ISO 8.8 to SAE Grade 5 or ASTM A325? How does ISO 10.9 compare with SAE Grade 8 and ASTM A490? Start with the side-by-side minimum tensile strengths, then check the diameter and product specification before making a purchasing or substitution decision.
Fastener grade comparison tables
Compare by strength first. Similar tensile strength alone does not establish interchangeability. Check the thread system, dimensions, material, proof load, coating and assembly requirements against the drawing or contract.
ISO vs SAE vs ASTM bolt grades by minimum tensile strength
| ISO 898-1 class | ISO minimum tensile strength | SAE J429 comparison | ASTM general-use comparison | ASTM F3125/F3125M structural comparison |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 4.6 / 4.8 | 400 / 420 MPa | Grade 1 · 60 ksi (≈414 MPa), ¼–1½ in. Grade 2 also has a 60 ksi band above ¾ in. through 1½ in. | A307 Grade A · 60 ksi (≈414 MPa), general purpose | — |
| 5.6 / 5.8 | 500 / 520 MPa | Grade 2 · 74 ksi (≈510 MPa), ¼–¾ in. for bolts and screws up to 6 in. long | — | — |
| 6.8 | 600 MPa | — | — | — |
| 8.8 | 800 MPa at d ≤ 16 mm; 830 MPa at d > 16 mm. See the separate ISO structural provisions. | Grade 5 · 120 ksi (≈827 MPa), ¼–1 in.; 105 ksi (≈724 MPa) above 1 in. through 1½ in. | A449 · 120 ksi (≈827 MPa), ¼–1 in.; 105 ksi (≈724 MPa) above 1 in. through 1½ in.; 90 ksi (≈621 MPa) at 1¾–3 in. | A325 · 120 ksi (≈827 MPa); A325M · 830 MPa |
| 9.8 | 900 MPa at d ≤ 16 mm | — | — | — |
| 10.9 | 1,040 MPa | Grade 8 · 150 ksi (≈1,034 MPa), ¼–1½ in. | — | A490 · 150 ksi (≈1,034 MPa); A490M · 1,040 MPa |
| 12.9 | 1,220 MPa | — | — | — |
Each row groups selected fasteners with similar minimum tensile strengths in the indicated sizes. A dash means this guide lists no comparison for that row. Values marked ≈ are rounded unit conversions for reading across columns. Use the original specification units for acceptance. For SAE Grade 2 bolts and screws in the ¼–¾ in. diameter band that are longer than 6 in., J429 applies Grade 1 requirements. ISO 898-1 · SAE J429 · ASTM A307 · ASTM A449 · ASTM F3125/F3125M
How the comparisons change with size and application
- 8.8 vs SAE Grade 5. A general-purpose M20 class 8.8 bolt has an 830 MPa minimum. A ¾-in. Grade 5 bolt is close at about 827 MPa, while a 1¼-in. Grade 5 bolt has a 105 ksi minimum, about 724 MPa. The metric and inch threads have different mating requirements.
- 10.9 vs SAE Grade 8 vs ASTM A490. Their minimum tensile strengths sit near 1,040 MPa. A490 is a heavy-hex structural grade under F3125/F3125M. Its use depends on the specified assembly, coating, installation and inspection requirements. RCSC Specification
Reference tables by standard
The tables below give more detail on the ISO classes, stainless markings, and the separate specifications for structural bolting and nuts.
ISO 898-1 carbon and alloy steel bolts, screws and studs
| Property class | Nominal tensile strength (MPa) | Minimum tensile strength (MPa) | Size or application note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4.6 | 400 | 400 | Within standard scope |
| 4.8 | 400 | 420 | Within standard scope |
| 5.6 | 500 | 500 | Within standard scope |
| 5.8 | 500 | 520 | Within standard scope |
| 6.8 | 600 | 600 | Within standard scope |
| 8.8 | 800 | 800 | d ≤ 16 mm, general values; structural bolting has separate provisions |
| 8.8 | 800 | 830 | d > 16 mm; check the structural-bolting provisions separately |
| 9.8 | 900 | 900 | d ≤ 16 mm |
| 10.9 | 1000 | 1040 | Within standard scope |
| 12.9 | 1200 | 1220 | Within standard scope |
The ISO 898-1 designation uses the first number to express nominal tensile strength in hundreds of MPa. The second number gives ten times the nominal yield-to-tensile ratio. For 10.9, that gives 1,000 MPa nominal tensile strength and a nominal ratio of 0.9. The specified minimum tensile strength is 1,040 MPa. For acceptance, use the standard’s applicable minimum, proof load and test method for the actual size and product. d is nominal thread diameter. ISO 898-1:2013
ISO 3506-1 stainless bolts, screws and studs
| Designation | Stainless grade | Minimum tensile strength (MPa) | Minimum 0.2% proof stress (MPa) |
|---|---|---|---|
| A2-70 | A2 austenitic | 700 | 450 |
| A4-70 | A4 austenitic | 700 | 450 |
| A4-80 | A4 austenitic | 800 | 600 |
In A4-80, A4 identifies the stainless grade and 80 identifies the property class. A2-70 and A4-70 share the listed mechanical minima but differ in chemical requirements. The values shown are for the listed full-loadability designations under the standard’s applicable test conditions. Assess stainless grade against the service environment. ISO 3506-1:2020
SAE and ASTM general fastener specifications
| Designation | Product scope | What to verify |
|---|---|---|
| SAE J429 Grade 2 | Inch-series externally threaded steel fasteners | Check the product and diameter covered by the grade. |
| SAE J429 Grade 5 | Inch-series externally threaded steel fasteners | Use the size-specific requirements in J429. |
| SAE J429 Grade 8 | Inch-series externally threaded steel fasteners | Use the grade requirements and applicable markings in J429. |
| ASTM A307 Grade A | General-purpose carbon steel fasteners | Confirm the grade and product form in the order. |
| ASTM A449 | Heat-treated steel bolts, hex cap screws and studs | The tensile requirement varies with diameter. |
| ASTM A354 Grade BD | Quenched and tempered alloy steel externally threaded fasteners | Verify the specified grade, diameter and product form. |
| ASTM A574 | Alloy steel socket-head cap screws | Confirm inch-series product geometry and size-specific requirements. |
| ASTM F593 | Stainless steel bolts, hex cap screws and studs | Check alloy group, condition and size. |
Use the comparison above for selected tensile values and the cited SAE edition or ASTM specification for the full product requirements. SAE J429 · ASTM fastener standards catalog
ASTM F3125/F3125M structural bolts and assemblies
| Grade | Style | Minimum tensile strength | Nominal diameter range |
|---|---|---|---|
| A325 | Heavy hex | 120 ksi | ½–1½ in |
| A325M | Heavy hex | 830 MPa | M12–M36 |
| F1852 | Twist-off assembly | 120 ksi | ½–1¼ in |
| 144 | Heavy hex or twist-off assembly | 144 ksi | ½–1¼ in |
| A490 | Heavy hex | 150 ksi | ½–1½ in |
| A490M | Heavy hex | 1040 MPa | M12–M36 |
| F2280 | Twist-off assembly | 150 ksi | ½–1¼ in |
A325 and A490 survive as grade names under F3125/F3125M. Specify grade, type and style, and use the units for the specified series. For structural work, verify assembly components, coating, installation and inspection against the governing project documents and applicable structural bolting specification. Route proposed substitutions through the project’s approval process. ASTM F3125/F3125M-26 · RCSC Specification (AISC)
Nut specifications and property classes
| Designation or standard | Scope | What to verify |
|---|---|---|
| ISO 898-2 classes 5, 6, 8, 10 and 12 | Metric carbon or alloy steel regular or high nuts, as applicable | Use the permitted nut style, size and bolt pairing for the class. |
| ISO 898-2 classes 04 and 05 | Metric carbon or alloy steel thin nuts (style 0) | Reduced loadability. A jam-nut arrangement uses a regular or high nut as well. |
| ISO 3506-2 | Metric stainless steel nuts | Use the nut’s own grade, class, style and proof-load requirements. |
| SAE J995 | Inch-series steel nuts | Check the nut grade, dimensions and proof load. |
| ASTM A563/A563M | Carbon and alloy steel nuts, inch and metric | Check grade and suitability for the specified assembly. |
| ASTM F594 | Stainless steel nuts | Check alloy group, condition and applicable proof load. |
Nut performance is assessed using the applicable nut proof load and assembly rules. Use the mating guidance for the actual thread size, pitch and nut style. The leading zero in ISO 898-2 classes 04 and 05 belongs to the thin-nut classification. ISO 898-2:2022 · ISO 3506-2:2020 · SAE J995 · ASTM fastener standards catalog · ISO 4035:2023
Reduced loadability: what the leading zero means
8.8 and 08.8. ISO 898-1 uses 08.8 for a reduced-loadability fastener with the material properties of class 8.8. Its finished-product load depends on the limiting geometry and the applicable requirements. A leading zero gives no universal reduction factor. ISO 898-1:2013
A4-80 and A4-080. Under ISO 3506-1, 080 is the reduced-loadability marking symbol for class 80 when the applicable threaded-section tensile test can be performed. The class-level tensile value alone does not establish the load the complete screw can carry through its head or shank. For reduced-loadability fasteners whose nominal threaded length b is below 3d and prevents that test, ISO 3506-1 calls for the stainless grade marking and omits the property-class designation. See clause 10.1.3 and Table 14. ISO 3506-1:2020
Identify the product standard before classifying the screw. ISO 10642 hexagon socket countersunk screws and ISO 7380-1 hexagon socket button-head screws have reduced loadability by design. A conventional ISO 4762 socket head cap screw belongs to a different product standard. The presence of a socket or the inability to grip a short screw in a tensile fixture is insufficient to classify it as reduced-loadability. ISO 10642:2026 · ISO 7380-1:2022 · ISO 4762:2004
What to specify and ask the lab to verify
- Order the complete fastener. Record the product standard and edition, mechanical-property standard and designation, thread size and pitch, length, finish and any required nut or washer. For example, an M24 × 3 × 200 mm class 8.8 bolt also needs a product standard and finish.
- Check test applicability for the actual geometry. Ask the lab which finished-fastener tensile, wedge or proof-load tests apply to the steel part, or which ISO 3506-1 tests apply to the stainless part. For short parts, use the applicable method and acceptance criteria specified for the size, class and geometry. A specified torsional breaking test, where applicable, is a controlled mechanical test. A torque reading from tightening a nut measures joint behaviour and cannot establish tensile compliance. ISO 898-1:2013 · ISO 3506-1:2020 · ISO 16047
- Match the report to the delivered lot. Verify traceability, standard and edition, actual sample size and geometry, method, measured result, units, acceptance limit and disposition. For a reduced-loadability design, ask for the applicable finished-product breaking load and the basis for it. A mill certificate describes the material and cannot by itself establish the mechanical performance of the finished geometry.
Standards and further reading
References checked . Apply the edition specified by your drawing, contract or governing code.